Matt LeMieux

08 May 2007

Withdrawing the War Power


In our Constitutional Law classes we have been discussing the powers possessed by each branch of the American government. As we learned, Article I of the Constitution gives Congress the power to declare war. While the last actual declaration of war was just after the attack of Pearl Harbor, Congress has on many occasions passed resolutions giving the President the power to engage in hostilities on foreign soil. Most recently Congress did this with Iraq. While never specifically declaring war against Iraq, Congress did pass a resolution allowing the President to send troops there should he see fit. As we know, he saw fit. Currently the Democrat-controlled Congress and Republican President are at odds over when, or whether, to bring the troops back from Iraq. Congress has tried to pass funding bills that also include timetables for troop withdrawals. The President has resisted this effort by vetoing such bills.

Now comes an interesting proposal from someone who herself wishes to be President one day. Sen. Hillary Clinton has proposed that Congress withdraw the resolution it passed several years ago giving the President the authority to attack Iraq. The question that legal scholars are surely asking themselves at the moment is, can they do that? Once Congress gives the President the power to make war, can Congress withdraw that power? My hunch is no. But it does raise an interesting question.